The money is there. Now what?
Your LLC just had its first genuinely good month. Clients paid, the balance looks healthy, and you'd like some of that money to, you know, pay your rent. So you open the banking app, stare at the business account, and realize you have no idea what the correct move is. Transfer it? Write yourself a check? Pay yourself a salary like a normal employee?
You're not alone in this confusion — it's one of the most common questions new LLC owners ask, and the answer is genuinely tricky because it depends on how your LLC is taxed. Get it wrong and you won't go to jail, but you might overpay taxes, create a bookkeeping mess, or weaken the liability protection you formed the LLC for in the first place.
The good news: once you understand the two main systems, paying yourself becomes routine. Let's walk through both, plus the record-keeping habits that keep everything clean. This is general information, not professional tax or legal advice — your situation deserves a real CPA once money gets serious.
Method one: the owner's draw (default for most LLCs)
By default, the IRS doesn't see your single-member LLC as separate from you at all — it's a "disregarded entity," taxed like a sole proprietorship. Multi-member LLCs default to partnership taxation. In both cases, you don't get a salary. You take what's called an owner's draw: you simply move money from the business account to your personal account.
Here's the part that surprises people: the draw itself isn't a taxable event, and it's not a business deduction. You owe tax on the LLC's profits whether you take the money out or leave every cent in the account. Made $80,000 in profit and only drew $50,000? You're taxed on $80,000. The IRS taxes the profit, not the transfer — which means "leaving money in the business to avoid taxes" doesn't work the way people hope.
You'll also owe self-employment tax — Social Security and Medicare, currently 15.3% on net earnings — on those profits. That stings, and it's the reason the second method exists. But for businesses in their early years, draws are beautifully simple: take what you need, leave a buffer for taxes and expenses, and keep a record of every transfer.
Method two: salary plus distributions (the S-corp election)
An LLC can elect to be taxed as an S corporation by filing Form 2553 with the IRS. This doesn't change your legal entity — you're still an LLC under state law — but it changes the tax game completely. Now you're an employee of your own company, and the company pays you a salary through payroll, with income tax and payroll taxes withheld like any job.
The magic is in the split. As an S-corp, you pay yourself a "reasonable salary" — the IRS's term, and they do check — and take remaining profits as distributions. The salary gets hit with payroll taxes, but the distributions don't face the 15.3% self-employment tax. For profitable businesses, that gap is real money: on $120,000 of profit with a $70,000 reasonable salary, the $50,000 distributed sidesteps self-employment tax entirely.
But nothing is free. S-corp status means running payroll (monthly or quarterly filings), stricter bookkeeping, and the ever-subjective question of what counts as "reasonable" salary for your role. Set it absurdly low to dodge taxes and the IRS can reclassify your distributions as wages — with penalties. The election usually starts making sense somewhere around $60,000–$80,000 in annual profit, though that's a rule of thumb, not a law. Talk to a CPA before filing Form 2553; the election has deadlines and consequences.
The habits that keep you out of trouble
Whichever method you use, the unglamorous habits matter more than the strategy. First: separate accounts, no exceptions. Business money lives in the business account; personal money lives in yours. Every transfer between them gets labeled — "owner's draw, October" — in your bookkeeping. This isn't just tidiness; commingling funds is one of the fastest ways to weaken your LLC's liability protection.
Second: pay estimated taxes quarterly. Because no employer is withholding for you (unless you're on S-corp payroll), the IRS expects you to send estimated payments four times a year via Form 1040-ES. Skip them and you'll meet the underpayment penalty — essentially interest on the tax you should have sent earlier. A simple approach: every time money comes in, move 25–30% to a separate tax savings account before you touch the rest.
Third: document everything. Draws, distributions, salary payments, reimbursements for business expenses you paid personally — all of it gets recorded with dates and amounts. If you're ever audited, or if you ever need to prove the LLC is a real separate entity, this paper trail is your best friend. Accounting software helps enormously here; a shoebox of receipts helps far less.
Mistakes that cost real money
The classic blunder is treating the business account like a personal wallet — groceries, vacations, the occasional "I'll pay it back." Every one of those transactions is evidence that you don't respect the LLC as separate from yourself, which is exactly what a creditor's lawyer wants to show a judge. Pay yourself properly through draws or payroll, then spend from your personal account like a civilian.
The second blunder is the opposite: starving yourself to "reinvest everything" while the tax bill quietly compounds. Remember, the IRS taxes profit regardless of draws. Founders who leave everything in the business and then can't cover April's tax bill learn this lesson once, painfully. Your draw isn't selfish — it's how the system is designed to work.
The third is setting an S-corp salary by vibes. "Reasonable salary" means what someone would pay an unrelated person to do your job — check salary data for your role and region, document your reasoning, and revisit it as the business grows. A $20,000 salary on $200,000 of profit isn't clever; it's an audit invitation.
When to get professional help
You can absolutely handle draws and basic bookkeeping yourself in the early days. But three milestones mean it's time to hire a CPA: when profit consistently clears that $60,000–$80,000 range (S-corp analysis time), when you add partners or employees (payroll complexity explodes), and when you operate in multiple states (nexus rules multiply).
A good CPA doesn't just file your return — they model scenarios. Draws vs. S-corp at your actual numbers, quarterly estimate calibration, retirement plan options like a Solo 401(k) that can shelter serious money. The fee — often $1,000 to $3,000 a year for a small business — routinely pays for itself in avoided penalties and optimized elections. Think of it as buying the one subscription that actually saves you money.
Until then, keep it simple and keep it separate: take draws on a regular schedule (monthly works well), stash tax money first, and write everything down. Paying yourself from your LLC isn't complicated once the system is set — it's just a system most people never bother to set up. Now you will.